306 E Stadium Ave - Facade (Siding Replacement)
Description
The owner of this c.1955 contemporary-style home got approval to replace rotten wood board-and-batten siding (about 80% deteriorated) with LP engineered wood, keeping the vertical look and removing the chevron pattern. The narrow character-defining windows will be kept and handled in a separate COA.
Impact summary
A new homeowner is restoring a distinctive mid-century modern home in New Chauncey, keeping its historic character while using a durable modern material.
Applicant
- Address
- 306 E Stadium Ave, West Lafayette, IN 47906See this on the map
At a glance
- Hearings
- 3
- Public comments
- 0
- Total mentions
- 3
Last vote
A recommendation. The council’s outcome is not on record here.
Last discussed Jul 14, 2026.
Meeting timeline (3)
Historic Preservation Commission - Certificate of Appropriateness Subcommittee - Jul 14, 2026
Replacement of original fixed wood windows on a circa-1955 Contemporary-style home in the New Chauncey district, recommended for staff administrative approval due to severe deterioration.
Historic Preservation Commission - Jun 16, 2026
The owner of this c.1955 contemporary-style home got approval to replace rotten wood board-and-batten siding (about 80% deteriorated) with LP engineered wood, keeping the vertical look and removing the chevron pattern. The narrow character-defining windows will be kept and handled in a separate COA.
Historic Preservation Commission - Certificate of Appropriateness Subcommittee - Jun 9, 2026
Replacement of roughly 80% of the rotted wood siding on a circa-1955 contemporary home with LP Smart Siding in a matching board-and-batten pattern; the chevron feature will be removed. A separate window application follows.
Related issues (2)
Engineered wood siding in historic districts
The commission has never approved LP Smart Siding before, but members weighed it against Hardie Board, which they regularly allow. With 80% of the wood siding rotted, repair wasn't realistic, and the homeowner wanted a durable, longer-lasting material.
Window replacement in New Chauncey Historic District
A homeowner on E Stadium Ave needed permission to replace badly rotted original 1955 wood windows. The panel agreed repairs don't make sense and in-kind wood replacement preserves the home's contemporary character.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda, when it's voted on and when its status changes, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for West Lafayette
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.