228 Dehart Street - Garage
Description
A COA application for a stoop, step, fence, porch, garden shed, and balcony at a contributing c. 1955 Ranch house in the New Chauncey Historic District. Staff recommended denying the modern garage door but approving the concrete pad addition.
Impact summary
The change affects the street-facing character of a contributing historic home on a corner lot, so the door design matters to the whole district's look.
Applicant
- Address
- 228 Dehart Street, West Lafayette, IN 47906See this on the map
At a glance
- Hearings
- 4
- Public comments
- 1
- Total mentions
- 4
Last vote · Historic Preservation Commission
A recommendation, not a final decision. The council decides next.
Discussed at 2 meetings in the last 60 days; most recently Nov 17, 2026.
Meeting timeline (4)
Historic Preservation Commission - Nov 17, 2026
A ranch-style c. 1946 home's screened porch became a two-car garage; the owner submitted a revised wood-panel garage door matching the original and won unanimous approval.
Historic Preservation Commission - Certificate of Appropriateness Subcommittee - Nov 10, 2026
A homeowner converted a historic screened porch into a garage; the subcommittee sent the case to the full commission with a plan for a wood replacement door mimicking the original, pending drawings from the owner.
Historic Preservation Commission - Jul 21, 2026
A new three-car detached garage behind a non-contributing 1955 ranch home, with LP Smart Siding and a choice between two roofline designs — approved with the owner free to pick either.
Historic Preservation Commission - Certificate of Appropriateness Subcommittee - Jul 14, 2026
A new three-car garage behind a 1955 ranch house, revised through several iterations to reduce visual impact, approved as option A with an option B layout headed to the full commission.
Related issues (2)
228 Dehart Street garage conversion in New Chauncey Historic District
A homeowner converted a historic screened porch to a garage but installed a modern door visible from the street. The subcommittee is steering him toward a custom wood door that mimics the original, with final decision by the full commission.
Proposed three-car garage at 224 Dehart Street
Staff flagged a gravel driveway that doesn't meet zoning rules and a garage that may overwhelm the existing house in scale. The application returns next month with the applicant expected to attend.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda, when it's voted on and when its status changes, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for West Lafayette
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.