Public Safety↑ Rising

Flock cameras

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Supportive (7)Opposed (18)Concerned (2)

At a glance

Public comments
27
Last 30 days
0

Rising — discussed at 4 meetings since Sep 21, 2026, up from 0 in the two months before.

Public comments (34)

OpposedRob MyersNov 16, 2026

Rob Myers asked whether the Flock camera payout was owed or denied, whether the cameras are bagged, and about the Jason Peters situation; the board declined to answer, citing personnel privacy.

Marshall County Commissioner — November 16, 2026 · 51:08 →
SupportiveRobin MyersOct 12, 2026

A Plymouth resident begged the council to keep the cameras, citing drug trafficking and child predators locally, and said the cameras recently helped locate a baby just blocks away.

Marshall County Council — October 12, 2026 · 24:04 →
OpposedThor HebnerOct 12, 2026

Cited researcher ties to China's police ministry, Fourth Amendment rulings, and 20+ Virginia localities cutting Flock ties; called the tools of tyranny and asked for a statewide moratorium.

Marshall County Council — October 12, 2026 · 28:04 →
OpposedMelody NortonOct 12, 2026

Worried about unaccountable technology expansion, saying facial recognition is coming whether the sheriff admits it or not.

Marshall County Council — October 12, 2026 · 33:02 →
OpposedJewell EngelhaufOct 12, 2026

Said Bremen saw 1.7 million searches in 90 days, calling it extensive and crazy, and praised the council for listening to residents.

Marshall County Council — October 12, 2026 · 35:10 →
OpposedMark VogtOct 12, 2026

Argued government authority is limited to delegated powers, called the Flock program administrative creep, and urged denial of funding, quoting Benjamin Franklin.

Marshall County Council — October 12, 2026 · 36:31 →
OpposedNelson WashburnOct 12, 2026

Cited studies showing fewer than 2% of Flock scans produce actionable alerts and said he wouldn't run the program as a business.

Marshall County Council — October 12, 2026 · 39:01 →
SupportiveJenny BennittOct 6, 2026

Argued social media has already eroded privacy and that Flock cameras can save lives if given tighter restrictions.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:01:20 →
SupportiveDonna PontiusOct 6, 2026

Said there is no expectation of privacy in public and that bad actors misusing the system should be punished rather than the technology removed.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:04:02 →
OpposedRichard S. GibbsOct 6, 2026

Warned the cameras are another incremental step toward surveillance of private life and questioned why warrants are burdensome.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:05:12 →
OpposedAlyssia ZolmanOct 6, 2026

Opposed ALPR tracking but asked that if the system stays, audits be conducted monthly by an independent third party with public disclosure of misuse.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:06:54 →
SupportiveRobin MyersOct 6, 2026

Cited local cases — a kidnapped baby and a grandmother with Alzheimer's — found with Flock cameras and urged keeping every tool for law enforcement.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:08:24 →
OpposedJewell EgenlaufOct 6, 2026

Described struggling to get basic public records about the camera system's configuration and said civil liberties protections exist for the public.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:12:05 →
SupportiveBarb HolcombOct 6, 2026

Said both privacy and her granddaughter's safety can be true at once, and urged patience while courts and legislatures examine the issue.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:14:01 →
SupportiveDeborah VanDeMarkOct 6, 2026

Thanked the commissioners for the public meeting, said most people she asks do not want the cameras removed, and asked the board to back elected law enforcement officials.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:19:34 →
OpposedLaura BrockwayOct 6, 2026

Thanked the commissioners leading opposition, said constitutional rights trump other arguments, and asked the contract be cancelled without waiting for the courts.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:22:07 →
OpposedJeremy WentzelOct 6, 2026

Said he has home cameras by choice but does not want more government overreach or his data in the hands of government or third parties.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:23:10 →
OpposedDustin PeltzOct 6, 2026

Quoted Ronald Reagan on liberty versus security, calling the system state intelligence on innocent citizens and a step toward totalitarianism.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:24:01 →
OpposedDon NunemakerOct 6, 2026

A retired computer science instructor said he has seen totalitarian states' pervasive cameras and does not want that here.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:25:19 →
OpposedMark VogtOct 6, 2026

Demanded the board produce written proof of its legal authority to conduct mass surveillance, and asked that the program be suspended if it cannot.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:26:32 →
OpposedAndrew WolfOct 6, 2026

Said the issue is moving fast, noted polling shifts to roughly 60 percent opposed, and asked the board to reflect the majority and remove the cameras.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:29:13 →
OpposedThor HebnerOct 6, 2026

Compared Flock data collection to the Weimar-era records Hitler exploited and cited warnings that foreign adversaries can exploit the camera data.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:31:02 →
OpposedJason HallOct 6, 2026

Quoted Reagan's 'I'm from the government' line, said Indiana is a free state and questioned where surveillance stops, suggesting chipping license plates as the logical endpoint.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:34:02 →
OpposedCaleb CroyOct 6, 2026

A father of six, said he is against Flock because the system cannot be guarded and there is no oversight protecting against misuse.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:35:32 →
OpposedCurt JensenOct 6, 2026

Cited a Pilot News article showing 540,000 system searches in one month, 407 by Marshall County, and asked how many actually helped find anyone.

Marshall County Commissioner Special — October 6, 2026 · 1:36:22 →
ConcernedRobin MyersSep 21, 2026

Asked whether the county is locked into paying the Flock contract through 2028 or can exit; the county attorney explained the satisfaction guarantee clause.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 49:43 →
OpposedLaura BrockwaySep 21, 2026

Asked the commissioners to officially cancel the Flock contract following the county council's vote against funding, saying residents don't want government cameras watching them.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 53:39 →
OpposedLaura EbnerSep 21, 2026

A retired lieutenant colonel who backs law enforcement but opposes a surveillance state; called it insulting to be labeled a communist for opposing the cameras, noting communist China is itself a surveillance state.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 55:50 →
OpposedDustin FeltSep 21, 2026

Called for ending the surveillance state, citing hundreds of thousands of lookups in the county and calling the privacy invasion un-American.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 57:32 →
OpposedMark VoteSep 21, 2026

Quoted Jefferson and Franklin on liberty versus safety, saying the people of Marshall County do not want to be surveilled and formally requesting cancellation of the contract.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 58:05 →
SupportiveHeyla CrothwellSep 21, 2026

Supported the cameras, saying if her child went missing and the sheriff's tools were taken away, it would leave everyone in handcuffs; suggested renegotiating the contract rather than scrapping it.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 1:00:10 →
OpposedUnidentified ResidentSep 21, 2026

A parent of six said he doesn't believe the cameras protect his children any more than he can, and is against them.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 1:00:34 →
ConcernedJoshua CrewSep 21, 2026

A cybersecurity company owner urged that any county system have routine audits, checks on unauthorized access, and compliance with state regulations and constitutional rights.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 1:01:27 →
SupportiveRobin MyersSep 21, 2026

A 65-year-old great-grandmother urged a hybrid approach: keep the cameras with guardrails like regular audits and penalties for misuse, citing a missing-baby case found within hours.

Marshall County Commissioner — September 21, 2026 · 6:01 →