High PriorityDevelopmentopen

Story Cottage memory care facility

Summary

The memory care facility on Brooks School Road that divided neighbors last month was approved by City Council on a 6-1 vote. The Plan Commission had declined to make a recommendation, so the final call went to the council.

At a glance

Total mentions
5
Last 30 days
0

Last discussed Jul 1, 2026.

Impact analysis

💰Financial impact

Opponents warn of potential property value impacts and litigation costs for the city; the facility itself would be private-pay at roughly $11,000 a month.

✅Who benefits

Families needing memory care in the area gain a small, home-style facility option.

⚠️Who could be affected

Some nearby Breakwater, Sandstone, and Hamilton Proper residents remain concerned about traffic and the commercial character of the use.

Mentions & discussions (5)

MeetingJul 1, 2026approved

Planned Unit Development (PUD) Committee - Jul 1, 2026

A small 6,600 sq ft memory care home is planned on Brooks School Road in a residential area, with staff noting two allowed deviations from UDO standards due to the narrow site and a drainage swale.

MeetingMar 4, 2026

Plan Commission - Mar 4, 2026

The memory care facility on Brooks School Road that divided neighbors last month was approved by City Council on a 6-1 vote. The Plan Commission had declined to make a recommendation, so the final call went to the council.

MeetingFeb 23, 2026approved

City Council - Feb 23, 2026

A small residential-style memory care home for up to 12 seniors is coming to 0.86 acres on Brooks School Road. It fills a documented gap in senior housing for Fishers, but neighbors raised traffic and safety concerns on the road.

MeetingFeb 4, 2026

Plan Commission - Feb 4, 2026

A proposed 7,500 sq ft, 12-resident memory care home at Brooks School Road has split the community — aging residents and families want boutique memory care in Fishers, while nearby neighborhoods say a business doesn't belong on a residential road. The Plan Commission sent no recommendation, so the City Council will decide.

MeetingJan 20, 2026approved

City Council - Jan 20, 2026

A proposed 12-resident, luxury memory care home on 0.86 acres at 10990 Brooks School Road drew strong neighborhood opposition from the Breakwater subdivision over traffic, property values and commercial creep into an all-residential corridor. A neighborhood meeting is January 29 and the Plan Commission hearing is February 4.

Related development

We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda and when it's voted on, at most once a day.

The weekly brief for Fishers

What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.

Also follow nearby cities

Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.