Story Cottage memory care facility
Summary
The memory care facility on Brooks School Road that divided neighbors last month was approved by City Council on a 6-1 vote. The Plan Commission had declined to make a recommendation, so the final call went to the council.
At a glance
- Total mentions
- 5
- Last 30 days
- 0
Last discussed Jul 1, 2026.
Impact analysis
Opponents warn of potential property value impacts and litigation costs for the city; the facility itself would be private-pay at roughly $11,000 a month.
Families needing memory care in the area gain a small, home-style facility option.
Some nearby Breakwater, Sandstone, and Hamilton Proper residents remain concerned about traffic and the commercial character of the use.
Mentions & discussions (5)
Planned Unit Development (PUD) Committee - Jul 1, 2026
A small 6,600 sq ft memory care home is planned on Brooks School Road in a residential area, with staff noting two allowed deviations from UDO standards due to the narrow site and a drainage swale.
Plan Commission - Mar 4, 2026
The memory care facility on Brooks School Road that divided neighbors last month was approved by City Council on a 6-1 vote. The Plan Commission had declined to make a recommendation, so the final call went to the council.
City Council - Feb 23, 2026
A small residential-style memory care home for up to 12 seniors is coming to 0.86 acres on Brooks School Road. It fills a documented gap in senior housing for Fishers, but neighbors raised traffic and safety concerns on the road.
Plan Commission - Feb 4, 2026
A proposed 7,500 sq ft, 12-resident memory care home at Brooks School Road has split the community — aging residents and families want boutique memory care in Fishers, while nearby neighborhoods say a business doesn't belong on a residential road. The Plan Commission sent no recommendation, so the City Council will decide.
City Council - Jan 20, 2026
A proposed 12-resident, luxury memory care home on 0.86 acres at 10990 Brooks School Road drew strong neighborhood opposition from the Breakwater subdivision over traffic, property values and commercial creep into an all-residential corridor. A neighborhood meeting is January 29 and the Plan Commission hearing is February 4.
Related development
Story Cottage memory care facility
No vote tonight — neighbors from Breakwater strongly oppose, citing traffic, ambulances, property values and fear of commercializing an all-residential corridor. Neighborhood meeting Jan. 29; Plan Commission hearing Feb. 4; council vote expected late February.
Story Cottage PUD
If approved, the quiet residential stretch of Brooks School Road would gain a home-like memory care facility staffed around the clock, with parking and deliveries neighbors worry will add to an already tricky road.
Story Cottage Memory Care (RZ-26-1)
A $2.5 million private investment bringing boutique memory care to the neighborhood, with traffic studies showing fewer than five peak-hour trips.
We'll email you when it's on an upcoming agenda and when it's voted on, at most once a day.
The weekly brief for Fishers
What the council decided, in plain English — one email a week.
Free. Unsubscribe with one click any time. We never sell your email.