Zoning

Kroger rezone

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Opposed (21)Concerned (3)

At a glance

Public comments
24
Last 30 days
0

Discussed at 2 meetings in the last 60 days; most recently Oct 8, 2026.

Public comments (53)

OpposedStephen MannerOct 8, 2026

Cited UDO 3.5.2's 88,000-square-foot gas station exemption language and accused the town of applying the UDO's benefit of the doubt only to Kroger.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:46:16 →
OpposedKevin LawrenceOct 8, 2026

Attorney for the Mannors and neighbors urged denial or at minimum no approval while procedural issues and property-value evidence remain unanswered.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:35 →
OpposedJim SaidOct 8, 2026

Argued the process is broken: the plan changed substantially after the APC's unfavorable recommendation and should go back for review.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 4:53 →
OpposedBeth MayOct 8, 2026

Said the PUD was designed as a low-intensity buffer, questioned truck routes, overnight refrigeration trucks, and asked Kroger to drop the gas station.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 7:39 →
OpposedBrian HickmanOct 8, 2026

Raised safety of school bus stops and bike paths near truck deliveries, and warned a vacated big-box store would blight the town's southern gateway.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 10:56 →
OpposedAutumn SoykaOct 8, 2026

A real estate broker said buyers choose the area for quiet streets, and estimated the fuel station alone could cut property values 5-15%.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 13:47 →
OpposedSteph DudaOct 8, 2026

Questioned whether the town has a grocery access problem at all, and asked why residents must pay attorneys to be heard.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 16:31 →
OpposedMackenzie LyonsOct 8, 2026

Attorney argued the application fails the UDO's rezoning factors and cited an alleged conflict of interest by the planning staff member who prepared the staff report.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 19:40 →
OpposedStephanie MannerOct 8, 2026

Her yard abuts the site; she cited crime at nearby Krogers, impact on a neighbor's autistic son, poor buffer upkeep, and difficulties getting public records.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 22:10 →
OpposedDennis RosebroughOct 8, 2026

Said the number of contortions required proves this is the wrong site for a Kroger.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:25:57 →
OpposedRonda EstridgeOct 8, 2026

Owns four acres next to the site with no fence barrier planned; urged the council to watch the neighborhood meeting video and cited runoff and a 24-hour fuel reader.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:28:25 →
ConcernedChris KeeslerOct 8, 2026

Asked why a materially changed application doesn't go back to the Plan Commission that saw the original packet.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:31:30 →
OpposedSteve WestOct 8, 2026

Cited traffic estimates of 3,000-8,000 daily customer trips and warned the 267/Northfield intersection will be overwhelmed at peak hours.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:34:50 →
OpposedMichael DoadesOct 8, 2026

Lives directly behind the site; argued new developments with stores differ from inserting a store into an established neighborhood, and worried about creek pollution.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:37:54 →
ConcernedRichard JohnsonOct 8, 2026

Questioned truck backing maneuvers at the dock, the undivided Green Street exit, and noted the concrete wall commitment doesn't reach the longest-buffered residential property.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:40:59 →
OpposedCorbin CoffeltOct 8, 2026

A young resident: kids ride bikes on those roads, traffic will increase, and noise would keep him awake past his 8:30 bedtime.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:44:05 →
ConcernedDavid BlickhahnOct 8, 2026

Asked whether an EPA review covers parking-lot and fuel-station runoff that flows to waterways recycled into drinking water.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:44:43 →
OpposedThomas ColffeltOct 8, 2026

Worried commitments won't be enforceable like the broken Marsh promises, cited overnight deliveries and truck backing on Northfield, and said flatly the neighborhood doesn't want the store.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:47:30 →
OpposedStephanie MannerOct 8, 2026

Returned at the end: noted no non-Kroger supporters spoke, cited 400+ petition signatures, said the masonry wall is the one fixable issue, and noted the traffic study didn't account for the coming Walmart.

Town Council (Regular) - Oct 8, 2026 · 1:50:52 →
OpposedRonda EstridgeSep 24, 2026

Asked how the town could stop Kroger from going 24-hour later and noted the fence stops before the gas station and parking areas.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 3:00:00 →
OpposedJim SaidSep 24, 2026

Argued the substantially revised PUD proposal is legally improper without returning to the APC and asked the council to reject it as procedurally improper.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 2:05 →
OpposedDennis RosebroughSep 24, 2026

Asked the council to follow the APC's unfavorable recommendation, saying the 77,000-square-foot store exceeds the local-commercial designation in the comp plan and Heritage Hills PUD.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 4:13 →
OpposedStephen MannerSep 24, 2026

As a professional engineer, argued the C3 heavy-commercial store contradicts the comp plan's neighborhood-commercial designation and criticized 24-hour operations and PUD exceptions.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 7:01 →
OpposedStephanie MannerSep 24, 2026

Bordering homeowner cited truck noise, drainage and safety concerns for her young children and asked the council to wait until Ward 5's representative is present.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 10:01 →
OpposedChad DudaSep 24, 2026

Cited ten waivers from town standards, the loading dock moving closer to homes, and deferred stormwater review, asking the council to vote no.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 13:06 →
OpposedBrian HickmanSep 24, 2026

Warned about delivery trucks and children near the 267/Northfield intersection and the risk of a vacant big-box building if the store closes.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 16:00 →
OpposedKevin ByronSep 24, 2026

Father of a son with severe autism, asked the council to vote no, saying noise and lights would worsen his son's condition.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 19:11 →
OpposedBeth MaySep 24, 2026

Presented petitions with 373 online and 56 written signatures opposing the project and listed 49 permitted uses that could go on the site instead.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 21:04 →
OpposedTammy EarlsSep 24, 2026

Her property is one house away; raised well-water contamination, fuel-station runoff, drainage and tree-preservation concerns.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 24:00 →
OpposedRonda EstridgeSep 24, 2026

Owner of four adjacent acres with adopted animals; recounted the Heritage Hills approval history and asked the council to vote no.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 28:05 →
OpposedRichie CrawfordSep 24, 2026

AT&T development inspector who walks the site; warned of costly utility, driveway, and roadway infrastructure changes needed to make the site work.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 32:06 →
ConcernedNancy StinsonSep 24, 2026

Professional engineer who asked that the town release Kroger's engineering packet to the public and questioned the missing truck-turn and drainage analyses.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 36:21 →
SupportiveEric StemshornSep 24, 2026

A supportive voice: argued the revised plan addresses APC concerns and that the south side needs a grocery store.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 39:40 →
SupportiveJohn RaboldSep 24, 2026

Argued the parcel will be commercial regardless, that it sits on arterials, and that the $30 million project boosts school tax revenue.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 41:50 →
OpposedDavid WeyantSep 24, 2026

Self-described neutral observer who questioned Kroger's neighborhood engagement and past conduct regarding the former Marsh building.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 46:00 →
OpposedNancy StinsonSep 24, 2026

In final comments, urged the town to answer traffic and drainage questions before granting entitlement and asked that Kroger consider the Ronald Reagan corridor instead.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 2:29:19 →
OpposedStephanie MannerSep 24, 2026

Argued buffer measurements included land not owned by Kroger and that the changed PUD text is a new proposal that should return to the APC.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 2:32:00 →
OpposedJim SaidSep 24, 2026

Disappointed in the vote, he questioned what the purpose of the APC is if the council overrides its recommendation.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 2:05 →
OpposedDennis RosebroughSep 24, 2026

Asked whether downsizing the store disqualifies the gas station as an accessory use under the UDO's fuel-station spacing rule.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 4:13 →
OpposedDavid WeyantSep 24, 2026

Questioned why the UDO's neighborhood-commercial size limit is not applied and whether Kroger is playing by different rules.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 2:43:30 →
OpposedBrian HickmanSep 24, 2026

Returned to argue the store is unnecessary near the planned Walmart site and existing gas station, and asked that commitments be made public before the October 8 meeting.

Town Council (Regular) - Sep 24, 2026 · 16:00 →
OpposedReverend Jim SaidAug 24, 2026

Questioned whether the PUD amendment met UDO filing requirements — owner signatures, the 50% owner-support rule — and asked the commission to confirm legal sufficiency before considering the merits.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 1:49:04 →
OpposedStephanie ManorAug 24, 2026

Lives 43 feet from the proposed loading dock area; described safety, drainage and noise impacts on her young children and a disabled neighbor child, and asked the commission to vote no.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 1:52:33 →
OpposedChad DudaAug 24, 2026

Framed the case against the five rezoning criteria, arguing a 99,000 sq ft store with a fuel center is regional, not local, commercial and falls short on every criterion.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 1:56:13 →
OpposedRichie CrawfordAug 24, 2026

An AT&T inspector who detailed utility relocations, fiber equipment, road geometry and well-water concerns, asking who pays for infrastructure and whether the town benefits financially.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 1:58:44 →
OpposedAutumn SoikaAug 24, 2026

A real estate broker testifying the project would hurt property values and resale for nearby owners, and offering a list of conditions including a masonry wall, 8-foot berm, limited hours and no loading dock near homes.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 2:01:31 →
OpposedBrian HickmanAug 24, 2026

Argued the Northfield/Green intersection is unsafe, that truck traffic would burden neighborhood streets and school-bus routes, and that a vacant big-box would harm the town's southern gateway if the store fails.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 2:04:45 →
OpposedSteph DudaAug 24, 2026

An educator suggesting park, trails or outdoor learning space as alternatives, and noting more than 350 residents signed the opposition petition.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 2:07:52 →
OpposedUnidentified ResidentAug 24, 2026

A 25-year resident who said buyers were promised no commercial on this land, and objected to a gas station near her home given her chronic health condition.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 2:13:03 →
SupportiveScott SmithAug 24, 2026

A Heritage Hills homeowner who supports the project despite personal misgivings, citing Senate Bill 1, TIF pressure and the need for commercial taxpayers outside the TIF — while urging the town to prevent Kroger from sitting vacant on the old Marsh site again.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 2:16:07 →
SupportiveEric StemshornAug 24, 2026

South-side renter supporting the store for grocery access, bikeability, jobs and keeping spending in Brownsburg, while acknowledging concerns about the fuel center.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 2:19:25 →
SupportiveJohn RapelAug 24, 2026

A former CR 267 resident who recounted the parcel's commercial zoning classification, taxation and comp-plan history and called approval a housekeeping exercise.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Aug 24, 2026 · 2:22:25 →
NeutralMacy DowneyJul 27, 2026

The applicant's representative asked for a continuance of the Kroger rezone to August 24, which the commission granted as a matter of right.

Advisory Plan Commission (Regular) - Jul 27, 2026 · 2:30 →